Signature Smash Burgers

Our burgers start with a custom 1/4 lb patty made exclusively for Milk Can Hamburgers—a rich blend of seasoned beef and brisket crafted for bold, unforgettable flavor. Each patty is smashed and seared on a hot griddle to lock in juices and create that perfectly crispy edge, delivering a mouthwatering balance of tenderness and texture in every bite. Simple, crave-worthy, and made the way a great burger should be. Add additional burger patty $3/ea. Add Smoked Bacon $2. Sub Impossible Patty $1.50/ea. Add Cheese $.50. Add Avocado $2. Sub Gluten Free Bun $1.50.

• Jack's Gold$8.99

  American Cheese, Ranch Cream Cheese, Bacon, BBQ Sauce, Onion Rings, Homestyle Bun

• The Milk Can Melt$7.29

  American Cheese, Caramelized Onions, Hellmann’s Mayo, Pullman White Bread

• Mushroom Swiss Burger$7.49

  Swiss Cheese, Hellmann’s Mayo, Sauteed Mushrooms, Homestyle Bun

• Jalapeno Popper Burger$9.99

  Deep Fried Ranch Cream Cheese Jalapeño Popper Patty, Pepperjack Cheese, Bacon, Spicy Ranch, Homestyle Bun

• Farmhouse Burger$7.49

  American Cheese, Dill Pickle, Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato, Horseradish Sauce, Homestyle Bun

• LegenDairy$9.49

  Swiss Cheese, American Cheese, Cheese Curds, Caramelized Onions, Dijonnaise, Pretzel Bun

• PB&J Burger$7.99

  American Cheese, Creamy Peanut Butter, Bacon Jam, Homestyle Bun

Diner Classics

• Blue Ribbon Ham$9.49

  Pulled Ham, Ranch Cream Cheese, Swiss Cheese, Dijonnaise, Dill Pickle, Granny Smith Apple, Pretzel Bun

• Hot Ham & Cheese$7.99

  Pulled Ham, Cheese Sauce, Stone Ground Mustard, Hellmann’s Mayo, Homestyle Bun

• Tuna Melt$8.99

  Albacore Tuna Salad, Ranch Seasoning, American Cheese, Toasted Multigrain

• Turkey Club$9.49

  Oven Roasted Turkey, Smoked Bacon, Ranch Cream Cheese, Mixed Berry Jam, Lettuce, Tomato, Toasted Multigrain

• MC-BLT$7.99

  Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Ranch Cream Cheese, Homestyle Bun

Soup & Salad

Add grilled or fried chicken to any salad +$3.99

• Chili$4.99/Cup$6.99/Bowl

  Shredded Cheddar, Sour Cream, Diced Onion

• Soup Specials

  Available while supplies lasts: Chicken Dumpling, Tomato Soup

• House Salad$4.99/Side$8.99/Regular

  Mixed Greens, Sliced Cucumber, Cherry Tomato, Red Onion, Seasoned Croutons • Dressing: Ranch, French, Italian, Balsamic, Thousand Island

• Door County Salad$10.99

  Mixed Greens, Dried cherries, Praline Pecans, Gorgonzola Cheese, Granny Smith Apple, Balsamic Dressing

• Chopped Cobb Salad$14.99

  Choice of Turkey or Grilled chicken, Mixed Greens, Bacon, Blue Cheese, Avocado, Egg, Cherry Tomato, Sliced Cucumber, Red Onion, Seasoned Croutons, Ranch

Classic Smash Burgers

Our burgers start with a custom 1/4 lb patty made exclusively for Milk Can Hamburgers—a rich blend of seasoned beef and brisket crafted for bold, unforgettable flavor. Each patty is smashed and seared on a hot griddle to lock in juices and create that perfectly crispy edge, delivering a mouthwatering balance of tenderness and texture in every bite. Simple, crave-worthy, and made the way a great burger should be. Add additional burger patty $3/ea. Add Smoked Bacon $2. Sub Impossible Patty $1.50/ea. Add Cheese $.50. Add Avocado $2. Sub Gluten Free Bun $1.50.

• The Milk Can Hamburger$6.49

  Ketchup, Yellow Mustard, Hellman's Mayo, Caramelized Onions, Dill Pickle

• The Milk Can Cheeseburger$6.99

  American Cheese, Ketchup, Yellow Mustard, Hellman's Mayo, Caramelized Onions, Dill Pickle

Chicken Sandwiches

Fried or Grilled on a homestyle bun

• Classic$7.99

  Hellmann’s Mayo, Dill Pickle

• Chicken Bacon Ranch$10.29

  Smoked Bacon, Ranch Dressing, Cheddar Cheese

• Spicy$8.99

  Nashville Hot Oil, Dill Pickle, Creamy Coleslaw, Spicy Mayo

• Buffalo$9.49

  Buffalo Sauce, Ranch Dressing, Bleu Cheese

• Cali$9.99

  Avocado, Hellmann’s Mayo, Pickled Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato

• Garlic Parmesan$8.99

  Garlic Parmesan Sauce, Pickled Red Onion, Lettuce, Tomato

Chicken Bites

Hand-breaded with a choice of dipping sauce: Carolina Gold BBQ, BBQ, Honey Mustard, or Ranch • Choose from: Spicy, Buffalo, BBQ, or Garlic Parmesan

• Classic Chicken Bites$5.49/6 Pieces$7.99/10 Pieces
• Specialty Chicken Bites$6.49/6 Pieces$8.99/10 Pieces

  Sauced & Tossed

Hot Dogs

1/4lb Nathan's All Beef Hot Dog on a buttery toasted Turano split top bun • Bacon wrap and deep fry your dog +$1.79

• Classic Dog$4.99

  Ketchup, Yellow Mustard

• Wisconsin Dog$5.49

  Ranch Cream Cheese, Dill Pickles

• Chili Dog$6.99

  Chili, Cheese Sauce, Diced Onion, Shredded Cheddar

• Danger Dog$7.99

  Bacon Wrapped & Deep Fried Dog, Spicy Mayo, Pickled Jalapeño, Diced White Onion, Tomato

Sides

"Make it Loaded" - Add Cheese Sauce, Crumbled Bacon, Scallions +$2.49 | Add Cheese Sauce, Chili, Sour Cream, Scallions +$3.49

• French Fries$2.99$9.99/Family
• Tots$3.49$10.99/Family
• Onion Rings$3.99$12.99/Family

  Horseradish dipping sauce

• Wisconsin Cheese Curds$5.99$11.49/Family

  Buttermilk ranch

Fried Chicken Bite Snack Wraps

• Classic$5.99

  Cheddar Cheese, Hellmann's Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato

• Chicken Bacon Ranch$6.99

  Crumbled Bacon, Ranch Dressing, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato

• Spicy$6.29

  Nashville Hot Oil, Dill Pickles, Creamy Coleslaw, Spicy Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato

• Buffalo$6.49

  Buffalo Sauce, Bleu Cheese, Ranch Dressing, Lettuce, Tomato

Frozen Custard

Vanilla, Chocolate, or Featured Flavors

• Frozen Custard$3.29/1 Scoop$4.79/2 Scoops$5.99/3 Scoops

  Vanilla, Chocolate or 2 Weekly Flavors. Customize your flavor with assorted toppings.

Limited Time Only

Specials available while supplies lasts! Get them while you can!

• Sweet Potato Fries

  Waffle Fries: Marshmallow Dipping Sauce Available

Bakery

• Cookies$1.79/Single$6.99/4 Pack

  Chocolate Chip, Cookie and Cream, Peanut Butter

• Brownie$2.79/Single$9.99/4 Pack
• Caramelized Banana Bread$3.99/Single$14.99/4 Pack

  Miniature loaf topped with vanilla icing

• Cronut Bites$4.99/6 Pieces$8.99/12 Pieces$15.99/18 Pieces

  Mini croissant donuts tossed in cinnamon and sugar, hot fudge

• Cinnamon Roll$5.49/Single$18.99/4 Pack

  Homemade Cream Cheese Frosting

Sundaes

Topped with whipped cream and a cherry

• Hot Fudge$5.49

  2 scoops of vanilla custard, hot fudge, peanut crumble

• Turtle$6.99

  Vanilla & chocolate custard, hot fudge, caramel, praline pecans

• Fruity Pebble$5.49

  2 scoops vanilla custard, mixed berry jam, fruity pebbles

• Brownie$5.99

  Vanilla & chocolate custard, brownie bites, hot fudge

Specials

Our Beer Batter is made with Lakefront New Grist Gluten Free Beer. Cod, French Fries and Tater tots are fried in a dedicated gluten free fryer.

• Beer Battered Fish Fry$12.99/2pc$15.99/3pc

  Gluten-Free Beer Battered Cod, Coleslaw, Tartar Sauce, Rye Bread, and French Fries or Tater Tots

• Beer Battered Fish Sandwich$6.99

  Gluten-Free Beer Battered Cod, Tartar Sauce, Pickles, American Cheese

Menu

Add-Ons: 2 Scrambled Eggs +$2.99 | Smoked Bacon (3) +$2.69 | Pork Sausage Patties (2) +$3.59 | Turkey Sausage Patties (2) +$3.99 | Panckakes (2) +$3.99 | Tater Tots +$2.99

• Breakfast Sandwich$3.19

  Toasted English Muffin or Buttermilk Biscuit, Fried Egg, American Cheese, and Breakfast Sauce. Add Bacon or Sausage $1.79, Pulled Ham or Turkey Sausage $2.09

• Chicken Biscuit$8.49

  Toasted Buttermilk Biscuit, Southern Style Fried Chicken, Breakfast Sauce, Pickles

• Breakfast Burrito$7.99

  Scrambled Eggs, Cheese Sauce, Grilled Onions, and Poblano Peppers With a Choice of Smoked Bacon or Pork Sausage. Substiture Turkey Sausage or Pulled Ham +$.29

• Breakfast Burger$9.99

  1/4lb Seared Smashed Patty, Pepper Jack Cheese, Breakfast Sauce, Fried Egg, Tater Tots

• Classic Breakfast$9.99

  Scrambled Eggs, 3 Strips of Smoked Bacon, 3 French Toast Sticks

• Wisconsin Breakfast$11.99

  Scrambled Eggs, 2 Strips of Smoked Bacon, 2 Pork Sausage Patties, 3 French Toast Sticks

• French Toast Sticks$5.99

  5 Cinnamon Sugar French Toast Sticks served with Syrup

• Caramelized Banana Bread$3.99

  Miniature Loaf of Homemade Banan Bread Topped with Vanilla Icing

• Turtle French Toast Sticks$8.99

  Caramel, Fudge Sauce, Pecan Pralines

• Reese's Peanut Butter French Toast Sticks$8.99

  Peanut Butter, Reese's Peanut Butter Cup Pieces

• Raspberry Oreo French Toast Sticks$8.99

  Raspberry Puree, White Chocolate Sauce, Oreo Pieces

• Cookie Butter French Toast Sticks$8.99

  Cookie Butter Sauce, Lotus Cookie Pieces

Frozen Custard

Dish, Cake Cone or Waffle Cone

• Vanilla or Chocolate$3.29/1 Scoop$4.79/2 Scoops$5.99/3 Scoops

Sundaes

Topped with Whipped Cream and a Cherry

• Hot Fudge$5.49

  2 Scoops of Vanilla Custard, Hot Fudge, Peanut Crumble

• Turtle$6.49

  Vanilla & Chocolate Custard

• Fruity Pebble$5.49

  2 Scoops of Vanilla Custard, Mixed Berry Jam, Fruity Pebbles

• Brownie$5.99

  Vanilla & Chocolate Custard, Brownie Bites, Hot Fudge

Bakery

• Cookies$1.79/each$6.99/4 pack

  Chocolate Chip, Cookies and Cream, Peanut Butter

• Brownie$2.49/each$9.49/4 pack

  Fudge Brownie

• Caramelized Banana Bread$3.99/each$14.99/4 pack

  Miniature Loaf with Vanilla Icing

• Cronut Bites$4.99/6 Piece$8.99/12 Piece$15.99/18 Piece

  Mini Croissant Donuts Tossed in Cinnamon Sugar and served with Hot Fudge Dipping Sauce

• Classic Cinnamon Roll$5.99

  Served Warm with Cream Cheese Frosting

• Cookie Butter Cinnamon Roll$6.99

  Served Warm with Cream Cheese Frosting, Cookie Butter Sauce & Cookie Butter Pieces

• Turtle Cinnamon Roll$6.99

  Served Warm with Cream Cheese Frosting, Chocolate Sauce, Caramel Sauce and Pecan Pralines

• Raspberry Oreo Cinnamon Roll$6.99

  Served Warm with Cream Cheese Frosting, White Chocolate Sauce, Raspberry Puree and Crumbled Oreos

Beverages

• Fountain Beverage$1.99/Small$2.39/Regular$2.79/Large

  Coke | Diet Coke | Dr Pepper | Explorium Root Beer | Sprite | Fanta Orange | Mellow Yellow | Minute Maid Lemonade | Blue Powerade

• Bottled Water$1.99
• Juice Boxes$3.49

  Fruit Punch or Apple

• Juice$2.49/Small$3.49/Large

  Lambeth Grove Orange

• Milk$1.99/Small$2.49/Large

  Sassy Cow 2% or Chocolate

• Coffee$1.99/Small$2.49/Large

  Regular or Decaf • Milk options: Almond, French Vanilla, Half & Half, Whole

• Anodyne Cold Brew$4.99/Small$5.49/Meidum$5.99/Large
• Cold Brew Custard Shake$5.99/Small$6.49/Medium$6.99/Large

Refreshers

• Blueberry Lemon$4.49/16 oz$5.49/20 oz

  Blueberry Puree, Lemonade, Sprite

• Black Raspberry Watermelon$4.49/16 oz$5.49/20 oz

  Black Raspberry Syrup, Watermelon Syrup, Sprite

• Strawberry Mango$4.49/16 oz$5.49/20 oz

  Strawberry Puree, Mango Syrup, Sprite

Dirty Sodas

Dirty Sodas are mixed with our House Custard Mix

• Cherry Delight$4.99/16 oz$5.99/20 oz

  Coca-Cola, Cherry Syrup, Custard Mix

• Raspberry Lemon Fizz$4.99/16 oz$5.99/20 oz

  Sprite, Raspberry Syrup, Citrus Syrup, Custard Mix

• Orange Dream$4.99/16 oz$5.99/20 oz

  Fanta Orange, Vanilla Syrup, Custard Mix

• Butterbeer$4.99/16 oz$5.99/20 oz

  Root beer, Caramel and Buterscotch Syrup, Custard Mix

• "Kiddie Cocktail"$4.99/16 oz$5.99/20 oz

  Sprite, Cherry Syrup, Custard Mix

Coffee, Tea & Hot Chocolate

Monin Flavored Syrups: Brown Butter Toffee, Butterscotch, Caramel, Cinnamon Bun, Cookie Butter, Gingerbread, Hazelnut, Honey, Irish Cream, Toasted Marshmallow, Vanilla, White Chocolate

• Anodyne Coffee$1.99/12 oz$2.49/16 oz$14.99/Bag

  "Bass Bay Brewhouse" Blend. Beans Available

• Cold Brew Coffee$4.99$5.49$5.99

  Monin Flavored Syrups Available. Milk Options: Whole Milk or Half & Half

• Iced Tea$1.99$2.39$2.79

  Rishi Classic Black Unsweet Tea

• Hot Chocolate$4.99

  Steamed Custard Mix, Classic Cocoa Powder

• Smore's Hot Chocolate$5.99

  Steamed Custard Mix, Hot Chocolate Mix, Marshmallow Fluff, Chocolate Syrup, Toasted Marshmallow Sauce, Graham Crackers

• Apple Cider$4.99

  Alpine Spiced Hot Apple Cider

• Caramel Apple Cider$5.99

  Alpine Spiced Hot Apple Cider, Caramel Syrup

Classics

• Shake$3.99/Small$5.49/Large

  Vanilla or Chocolate. Blend in your favorite toppings or syrups!

• Malt$4.49/Small$5.99/Large
• Custard Bar Toppings

  Brownie Bits, Butterfinger, Caramel Sauce, Cherry, Chocolate Chips, Cookie Butter Sauce, Cookie Dough Pieces, Crushed Peanuts, Fruity Pebbles, Heath, Hot Fudge, M&M's, Marshmallow Sauce, Oreo, Peanut Butter, Pecan Pralines, Rainbow Sprinkles, Raspberry Sauce, Reese's, Snickers, Strawberry Sauce

• Custard Float$4.99/1 Scoop$6.49/2 Scoops

  Root Beer, Dr. Pepper or Orange Fanta

Specialty Shakes

• Cookie Butter$6.99

  Vanilla Custard, Biscoff Cookie Butter, Graham Crackers

• Peanut Butter Bliss$6.99

  Vanilla Custard, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow Sauce, Crumbled Peanut Butter Cookie

• Chocolate Covered Strawberry$6.99

  Vanilla Custard, Chocolate Sauce, Strawberry Sauce, Brownie Bites

• Kitchen Sink$7.99

  Vanilla Custard, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, Heath Bar, Snickers, Brownie Bites, Caramel

Available for Dine-In & Takeout. Must be 21+.

• Brandy Alexander

  Brandy, Dark Creme de Cacao, Vanilla Custard Shake Mix

• Irish Alexander

  Whiskey, Dark Creme de Cacao, Vanilla Custard Shake Mix

• Grasshopper

  Creme de Menth, Creme de Cacao, Vanilla Custard Shake Mix

• Brandy Old Fashioned

  Brandy, Triple Sec, Luxardo Cherry Liqueur, Vanilla Custard Shake Mix

Bottles & Cans

• Explorium Hard Root Beer

  ABV 5%

• Brandy Old Fashioned

  Drink Wisconsinbly - ABV 7%

• Orange Vodka Cocktail

  Drink Wisconsinbly - ABV 5%

• Carbliss

  Cranberry, Margarita, Black Raspberry, Pineapple, Peach

• High Noon

  Peach, Grapefruit, Watermelon

• Archer Roose Sauvignon Blanc

  ABV 12.5%

• Bloody Mary

  Zing Zang - ABV 9%

Tap Beer

• Audrey's Amber
• Milk Can Lager
• Spotted Bass
• Wayfinder

Boozy Shakes

• Brandy Alexander

  Brandy, Creme de Cacao, Vanilla Shake

• Grasshopper

  Creme de Menthe, Creme de Cacao, Vanilla Shake

• Irish Alexander

  Whiskey, Creme de Cacao, Vanilla Shake

• Old Fashioned

  Brandy, Triple Sec, Vanilla Shake